Bewertung Verteidigung (AP)

Criteria

1

2

3

4

F

Annotations

Structure






Structure


macro structure, agenda and topics (definition, segmentation, followed, segmentation), consistent thread






micro structure, readability, highlighting, orientation (page numbers),






Performance






Performance


authenticity, audience centricity and orientation, appearance, language, media






fit of speech and visualisations, timing, weighting, story telling






Content






Content

current status and definition of problem according to complexity






goals and objectives named, solution path planned, research questions stated and reflected






Scientific reasoning






Scientific reasoning


introduction of methods, tools and approaches, theoretical foundation, integration and handling of sources






problem and goal oriented reasoning and conclusion, relevancy in regard to problem, differentiation in argumentation






Transfer, value






Transfer


utilizes and demonstrates knowledge transfer into practice; explanation of use and application of the methodology in regard to the specific problem






gain of knowledge, value, optimization/ improvement for customer through processed knowledge; generalization, transferability of the methodology for similar/other problems






Notenschlüssel